Wednesday, September 12, 2018

415. Confusion About the National Anthem



When we show respect for the anthem and the flag we are not showing respect for people we are showing respect for laws, the system that protects, among many other things, our right to protest, to peaceably assemble and speak out — as NFL players are doing.

They do this without the risk of being thrown in jail, as in other systems they might.  Here it's just a matter of etiquette where they are legally free not to stand and I am legally free to call it bad manners and confused thinking.

It's a deep kind of confusion with a long history.  Socrates' friends were confused when they wanted him to escape prison because the people who put him there were so wrong.  Socrates won't do it because it would break, and therefore injure, the laws of Athens, which he has enjoyed the benefits of.  Those who convicted him wronged him, made him a victim, as many of our juries do to people, but they were acting within the law, as our juries are.  Socrates patiently shows his friends that he is "not a victim of laws but of men."

As many rightfully aggrieved blacks in our day are.  As, to my understanding, the blacks in Jefferson were.  The laws about police behavior were OK; the still-white police force in a majority black community simply hadn't caught up to them.    

It would be much easier to avoid confusion if the victimized  would avoid the expression "institutionalized racism."  That's a big charge (it takes in our laws), it's much harder to nail down (I have yet to see that done), and it shouldn't be made without specifying the institution and showing how it is racist. Leave it vague and you let careless readers think their victimization is much deeper than it is.  And much harder to end.

No comments:

Post a Comment